The Supreme Court decision granting equal marriage rights to gays is bringing fear mongers out of the closet. Nathan Lewin’s op/ed My Rabbi Needs Legal Aid in The Jewish Exponent strives to instill in the Orthodox community a wholly unnecessary fear of gay rights. The article argues that an Orthodox rabbi may be forced to officiate at a gay wedding, contrary to the view of marriage expressed in Genesis 2:24, “A man shall leave his father and mother and cling to his woman and they shall become one flesh.”
The Supreme Court is, of course, precluded by the First Amendment from adopting the Bible as its law. Separation of church and state requires that it find other bases for decisions.
When two important Constitutional rights collide — say my right of equal protection of the laws and your freedom of religious practice — courts need to decide which right prevails. Contrary to the Nathan Lewin’s worries, the trend today is full tilt in favor of religion.